Guess some won’t agree with this but here’s an email I received today:
Dear Kevin, Dear Fellow Europeans,
A little over 6 months ago, 147,000 of us stood together to fight for our rights as EU Citizens and to sign a petition for UK Citizens to retain EU Citizenship and Rights .
So much has happened in this short time, that we thought this would be a good moment to update you on the progress of what has now developed into a significant landmark legal case (T-252/20) “EU Citizenship is a Permanent Status ” in the European Courts of Justice (CJEU).
Thanks to your support, on April 23rd of this year, our case was submitted - and now that the Council of the EU has responded, the next step is to present our arguments to prove that we have the power to retain our rights. How we move forward from here depends on the court - though we are expecting full legal proceedings to commence from January 11th .
We don’t know the full extent of the legal costs that will be required, and it is likely that we will need to raise additional funds as this case progresses, as is normal with cases of this importance. For this reason, we have increased our fundraising goal to £150,000 for this next vital stage of the case.
If you can, please contribute to our legal costs and help us raise the funds we need to take this case to its conclusion in the CJEU:
https://www.crowdfunder.co.uk/eu-citizenship-is-a-permanent-status
My thanks go to each and every one of you for your significant contributions to date, and for your help in bringing this legal challenge forward - we feel proud and honoured to represent all UK Citizens and to be defending this crucial cause for us all.
Here is some additional context on the legal proceedings:
Response to the Council
The defendant in our case, the Council of the European Union, has now responded to our application of 23 April 2020.
The council is arguing that all 66 million UK citizens (i.e. you and I) have no standing to bring this case in the Court of Justice of the European Union. What the council are essentially saying is that we have no power to stop them removing our EU Citizenship and rights. This is in stark conflict with the legal opinions received so far that no one has the power to take away our EU Citizens rights .
Our lawyers have submitted what we consider the most robust response possible to this so-called plea of inadmissibility. We also think that we should have a good chance of overcoming this hurdle based on general principles of judicial protection.
There are three possible ways forward from here: the Court agrees with us and we move forward to the substance of our case; the Court decides that our application is inadmissible, in which case we can appeal to the European Court of Justice, or the Court chooses to combine admissibility and substance.
Timescales before the CJEU are difficult to predict, even without the COVID-19 pandemic, and depend on variables such as whether the Court decides that the Council and ourselves will have another opportunity to respond to each other; and/or whether there will be a hearing before it decides on the way forward.
In addition, a number of organisations based in several European countries have applied to intervene in our case in our support. This is obviously good news as it means that our case has (already) reached a European-wide dimension.
The Court will, however, not decide on the admittance of these interveners before it has decided on the way forward with the Council’s plea.
In any event, there will probably not be any further decision before the end of this year - we will, of course, update you about any further developments in the case.
We believe that it cannot be right for politicians and bureaucrats to be able to take away the rights of citizens, without their agreement, at the mere stroke of a pen.
The legal advice we have received tells us that we can win this fight - and standing together, we may well be making legal history in the process.Please help us fight this case if you can.
Best regards,
Joshua Silver
Professor of Physics,
University of Oxford
EUCitizenship.org.uk