I offer this as a comment /POV… to avoid being dragged into yet another round of vitriolic shit slinging with evil bastards.
‘Social integration’ is a rather loose and broad term… it also has two levels with repsect to individuals and communities. These two levels are obviously linked, but should be viewed on from different time perspectives.
With individuals, they can only chose to ‘integrate’ within their own lifespan… or not… so its something tangible that we can review within a relatively short period of time. Younger immigrants tend to find this easiest and tend to respond and adopt some more local customs quickly into their way of life and culture… the older granny brought over once settled, is unlikey to learn the language, because its fucking tough to learn a new one when 40+ let alone 65+, nor is it easy to change your cutural identify when 80% of your life has been lived in acertain way with certain ideals and values, no matter how much you might wnat to… to expect folks to do is at best unreasonable.
Less tangible is ‘community integration’ - and to be homst I have yet to see a decent definition of integration in the first place because there are various issues at play, not least religious and cultural differences, but also the moral, ethical and legal diffrences that exist. Community integration takes longer and will depend on how strong these communities still value their orginal legacy - and yes religious ideiology will play a big part in this - yet we see again and again how on an individual basis, and in general the younger folks, do more readily adapt and move away from more traditional cultural practices… when left alone to do so.
From a legal perspective, everyone has to follow the laws of the land - no ambiguity there. However, (avoiding any naive moralizing) where culture clashes with local law, there does need to be an element of sensitivity as to how prosecutions are reported and processed - reporting crime is one thing, reporting it in terms of culture, race etc only serves to ingrain existing prejudices… it helps no one… a crime is a crime and that is it.
Moral and ethical differences based on cultural or religious ties are more challenging because its easy to focus on what divides us/the differences as it were, a rather nasty trick employed by the smarter racists, than all the great things we share and have in common - by focussing on what we have in common, integration is eased - because the differences become something that can be worked through over time… rather than becomming a ‘barrier to integration’ - the ignorant, yet ‘smart’ battle cry of the casual and not so casual racist.
Finally we have the biggest barrier to integration - fear and ignorance - the lack of senistivity and tolerance to diferent cultures and practices during the longer drawn out community integration phase… something driven by racists. Our own actions, fears and ignorance can create divisions where previously none existed, often fuelled by those with agendas on both sides… the evil IS like indoctrination only works when folks feel disenfranchised, lost and without purpose, or have been victimised, or racially bullied or worse - tell someone they are different, dont fit in, are lesser humans enough times and it cant be surprizing that zealot like fuckers with broader political agendas find a rich and fertile recruiting ground. Religion is not the divider, but merely the tool those with more radical political aims use to enslave
I dont hate all Christians because of a few fundmentalists who think being gay is a sin… I think they are all mad, but I dont hate them…
The problem I have with this thread…is the fact it was created, because by making such an inflamatory statement, it potentially becomes a self fullfilling prophecy… all sorts will add two penennth to the debate and there are plenty who will pretend its a very complicated question - but its not. Current culture only exists because of culturual evolution, the assimilation and integration of migrative populations… it just takes time. Sadly there are those who stand to gain from preventing or holding it back, and they feel they can achieve this by shouting loudly enough that its not working…